STYLES: STANDARD  |  PRINT NAVIGATE: CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Get the news with RSS!
MikeJer's Buffy Reviews
homereviewsarticleslinksdiscussion
<<Home
The Harvest>>

NO FUTURE FOR YOU PT. 4 (8x09)
<<Season 7 Review
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
A review by Mikelangelo "MikeJer" Marinaro,
March 24, 2008

Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Georges Jeanty

- Quick Links


WARNING: This is a retrospective review and may contain SPOILERS. Read at your own discretion.

- Review

What a wonderful end to this arc from Brian K. Vaughan! There's a lot going on here that I'm very pleased with ranging from how Faith currently sees the Mayor, her fight with Gigi and its somewhat surprising end, Buffy and Giles being on the outs, Faith and Giles creating an equal partnership, and the surprisingly intriguing reveal of the season's "Big Bad." Most of the material here could have been extremely overwraught and irrelevent, but so much of it turns out to have notable character significance. In all honesty, this is the very first time this season that I can say I don't have one major problem with an issue. So lets just dive right in!

I really can't express how pleased I am Vaughan didn't ruin Faith's relationship with the Mayor. Unlike what Whedon's done with Warren and S6, Vaughan avoids the trap of making repeat viewings of S3 less impactful by sticking true to what originally happened. What we see is what could easily be a deleted scene right out of "Graduation Day Pt. 1" (3x21) where the Mayor lays on even more genuine love for Faith. Her speech to herself is particularly tasty: "Scumbag. That's what most people think of the last guy who put me in a dress. But I don't know. Dude may have been a snake... but he wasn't a dog. Everybody thinks he was, like, exploiting me or whatever, but that's not how it felt. So I totally get how chicks can get mixed up in the wrong crap. Even today, it's still hard to look back at my time with that guy... and feel anything but loved." Thank you Vaughan! You deserve a big round of applause for making me love the Faith/Mayor relationship even more.

Having a flashback with the Mayor isn't just a fun treat, it's also relevant to the situation at hand. Even in the midst of a fight, Faith is doing her best to talk Gigi down and convince her that she's being used by Roden. Gigi says, "I should have listened to Roden." Faith quips back, "Who, Lucky Charms? If you want someone to be pissed at, try him. Trust me, dude is gonna be the death you." Faith is speaking from personal being-stabbed and put-into-a-coma experience. Similar to how the Mayor was to Faith, Gigi says, "He may push me, but Roden's also my best mate. Something I doubt you've ever had." Oh how I love it when everything ties together like this to develop a character.

What makes everything work here is how the relationship between Gigi and Faith has been built up just enough to the point where I buy their connection to each other. As "Pt. 2" really emphasized, they definately have some things in common. Faith's experience with the Mayor is really front and center here, which is why there's so much subtext referring to him in this dialogue. It all comes together when Faith really hits the mark telling Gigi "part of you knows something ain't right... 'cause you've never deserved to be loved by anybody." Wow, an extremely insightful comment from Faith that really shows how much she's understanding herself now and how far she's come since the old days. The fact she can reflect back on her time with the Mayor now and make these kind of conclusions says a lot.

It's at this point when Faith accidentally kills Gigi, which really brings everything full circle right back to Allan Finch the Deputy Mayor. All of Faith's development up until this point is succinctly moved forward here. The slaying of the Deputy Mayor in "Bad Girls" (3x14) is the event that sent Faith into darkness. The slaying of Gigi here, after all that growth, is what pulls Faith fully back into the light -- albeit a light gray light.

Afterwards, Faith and Giles -- who's not on speaking terms with Buffy anymore (more on this in a moment) -- both have a moment of bonding when Faith calls him on his own slaying of a human (Roden). He says, "It's a side of myself I'd rather not expose to those under my watch, but I have used lethal force before." Faith aptly responds, "Don't make it any easier." Giles: "No, it doesn't." It's about at this point when Faith comes up with the idea of spending her time now to try to help others like Gigi. This is really a beautiful development for Faith which I couldn't be happier with. Not only does it make sense out of what came before, but the idea of Faith using her knowledge and experiences in an effort to help bring troubled slayers back from the brink is simply brilliant. Giles' suggestion of working together, as equals, is simply bonus joy. It's beginning to look like Faith is Giles' new "main girl."

This, of course, leads me to thinking about why Buffy and Giles aren't on the best of terms. Essentially their conversation here involves Buffy demanding Giles fill her in on Faith's mission and Giles refusing to give that information, saying "...No. I don't want you to be any part of this." I believe their issues very clearly stem from the events of "Lies My Parents Told Me" (7x17). Giles has been up to all kinds of shady stuff behind Buffy's back, although none of it seems to be completely opposed to Buffy's agenda. I just have a feeling that Giles really isn't on the same page as Buffy anymore and possibly disagrees with how Buffy has taken charge of this slayer army. I forsee some major rumblings between these two before this season is up. Although I'm intrigued by the follow-up from S7, I'm really hoping their issues eventually get the same stellar attention that Faith got here.

The last remaining bit to discuss in this issue is the fight sequences. Most of these in S8 have left me cold thus far (mainly due to the comic format), but this one really delivers. I think it works so well because of how powerful the character material is, which makes everything else resonate so much more. I particularly enjoyed the twist of Faith accidentally kicking Gigi onto an axe along with the manner in which Giles kills Roden. I did, however, find myself feeling that Faith tossing that book to Giles as Roden just stands there to be a bit contrived. Additionally, I felt a little short-changed by the fact that both of the arc's villains were easily dispatched at the end of the arc. This is a little too clean for my taste, but at least it was done in the service of characters containing far more depth than the villains. Plus, we also got our first clean shot of the Big Bad: Twilight (a.k.a. Floating Guy from "" [8x01]).

So, to wrap this one up I'll say that I was thoroughly satisfied by the way the arc panned out. I honestly didn't expect this great of a conclusion, and I really didn't expect to get this much tangible development for Faith. I find it odd that I'd (so far) prefer the work of a Buffy newcomer to that of Whedon himself. Although still flawed in spots, "No Future for You" is a solid, entertaining, and thoroughly accomplished piece of work of which I'm proud -- for the first time in comic form -- to say is part of the Buffyverse canon. Congrats Brian K. Vaughan! I hope to see you writing in S8 again!

The averaged overall score for the "No Future for You" arc rounds out at 90, an A-.



- Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)
Pros:
+  
Jeanty's art continues to improve.
+  
Xander telling Buffy "Er, maybe the boss just needs some alone time." Buffy aptly responds, "What other kind is there?"
+  
Faith smacking Roden with his own book.
+  
GILES: "Burst."
+  
Twilight wanting to end the age of magic. Now that's a fresh plot arc. I love the possibilities!
  
Cons:
-  
I could have done without the dwarf, but at least he's not annoying.


- Quotes
MAYOR:  
My dear Edna May, rest her soul, she and I never had a chance to bring a child into this world. But when I look into your eyes, I see a daughter she would have been proud to call her own.
FAITH:  
(Shyly) Thanks.
MAYOR:  
Now why don't you change into your play clothes? The blood of innocents is a real pain in the neck to wash out of cotton blends.

GIGI:  
You're not even English, are you? Where is that horrid accent from anyway? New York?
FAITH:  
For the record, I'm a Boston girl. You know, like the Tea Party?

GIGI:  
You're even less entitiled to your power than that blow-dried Princess of Whales was to hers. I should have listened to Roden.
FAITH:  
Who, Lucky Charms?

GILES:  
You can't give up, Trafalgar.
TRAFALGAR:  
Tell that to my last hundred wives.

GILES:  
Please, lives are at stake.
BUFFY:  
Yeah, like mine. Your Femme Nikita just tried to stuff me down a pool drain.

RODEN:  
You desparate old git. Did you honestly just try to use one of my own containment spells against me? I can break out of any mystic field ever enchanted.
GILES:  
I know. That's why I put one inside you. Burst.


- Score Learn about the Grading Scale
94/100 A-
Everything that an 'A' possesses, but with either a few more mistakes or slightly less power. Generally represents great episodes that are a tiny bit rough around the edges.


- Screencaps
<<Home
The Harvest>>

<<Season 7 Review
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

- Comments (4) View Today's Comments | Subscribe:

1.bookwormJan 16, 2008 (Wed)View This Person's Comments | Link
it's still Jeanty and Vaughan. And I always knew, that Vaughan is at least as good as Whedon when it comes to comics.

2.KevBotJan 18, 2008 (Fri)View This Person's Comments | Link
Well, as you stated, Joss is never terrific at season openers (note Marti Noxon's handling of "Bargaining, Part One" - now THAT'S how a season opener works), and "Anywhere But Here" and "The Chain" are already far better than "The Long Walk Home." Trust in Joss! Though I am happy that Vaughan's here. He's one of my favorites.

3.QueenPugJan 28, 2009 (Wed)View This Person's Comments | Link
I'm so disappointed that you won't be continuing to review the comics! I just finished re-reading the "Time of Your Life" arc and was wowed by how dark it's getting, Willow is back into the magics in a bad way and Buffy is losing her "moral certainty" just as Twilight foretold.
I do wish we could see this on tv as the emotional component is definitely muted in comics, but I've found that on reading through all of them again that they're better than I thought the first time around.

4.JohnnyDollarAug 16, 2011 (Tue) @ 8:16pmView This Person's Comments | Link
"Unlike what Whedon's done with Warren and S6, Vaughan avoids the trap of making repeat viewings of S3 less impactful by sticking true to what originally happened. "

Could you elaborate on this a little more? I went back and read your S6 season review and don't see any reference to it.

Great reviews by the way!


- Post a Comment
Name

(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.)
(*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***)

Security Code
Security Code

  

Copyright © 2012 CriticallyTouched.com, Mikelangelo Marinaro (e-mail me at: mikejer(at)criticallytouched(dot)com). All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of any review or article on this site is prohibited. All works and related characters are property of Joss Whedon, Mutant Enemy, 20th Century FOX, Universal Studios, Dark Horse Comics, and IDW Comics. I have no affiliation with Joss Whedon or any of those companies.