[LIGHT  |  DARK] NAVIGATE: CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Get the news with RSS!
homereviewsarticleslinksdiscussion
<<Home
The Harvest>>

NO FUTURE FOR YOU PT. 2 (8x07)
<<Season 7 Review
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
A review by Mikelangelo "MikeJer" Marinaro,
March 24, 2008

Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Georges Jeanty

*Warning: This review may contain spoilers from anywhere in the entire show.

- Quick Links


- Review

One could say that beginning this issue with a three page flashback to the moment Buffy stabs Faith in "Graduation Day Pt. 1" (3x21) is a way to get cheap mileage out of the past to lend credence to a comic book adaptation. I'm happy to say this is not the case, as this flashback has significant relevance to the story at hand. Faith's mission is to gut another slayer, just like Buffy did to her back in the day. The personal connection to the objective makes it significantly more difficult to accomplish. With this dilemma being the center of this issue, I'm already fond of it.

Rather than going in for the kill, Faith decides to take things at her own pace by disconnecting Giles and having some alone time first. After a few moments to herself, Faith finally meets Gigi, who clearly connects with her. This is a neat development, although not completely surprising considering they both have many shared personality traits. Although the very fact that Faith is doing this mission shows her change from before, it's obvious that she's still someone who hasn't completely shrugged off the attitude that she should be in it for herself. Gigi clearly has that mindset, and Faith smartly plays into the similarity.

I found a couple things in particular about their conversation interesting. The first being that Faith is calling herself Hope -- how intriguing. I feel the choice of this name reflects her feelings of "hope" for a better life for herself after Angel had so much "faith" in her. The second interesting thing is how, when asked about how her parents are doing, she tells the utter truth: "Dad may as well be a ghost and mum is a filthy drunk." It's at this point when Faith pulls the "hair knife" out, but for what purpose I'm not sure. Considering they were actually somewhat bonding, it's entirely possible she didn't intend to kill Gigi right there. My guess is that she was about to stab her. I do like how, after the gargoyle fight, Gigi wants to give "Hope" a shot, especially now that she knows Faith is a slayer that appears sympathetic to her.

So while I enjoyed the overall idea of "No Future for You Pt. 2," there's several things holding it back from working as well as intended. The first of which is some unusual clunky dialogue. While Briak K. Vaughan is able to nail the overall theme and even character voices, to an extent, some of the humor that's supposed to be witty feels forced, which is readily apparent in the Dawn/Willow scene. Most of this 'scene' doesn't sit well with me either. Willow's floating everywhere, Dawn's still not saying much of anything new or interesting about her situation, and their heart-to-heart gets conveniently interrupted. I find myself missing the direct follow-through we saw in "Doomed" (4x11): Buffy and Riley don't get to slip out of their important conversation there.

One last thing that bugged me was simply discovering that Gigi's motives are simply the same as the run-of-the-mill vampire: kill Buffy. My responses consist of "who cares" and "very uninteresting." It's to the issue's credit that this plot of hers is not the focus of the arc, Faith is. Fortunately the Faith material is actually pretty sharp in this entire arc. In the end, there's definately much more to like than dislike, but I'm still a tad disappointed Vaughan couldn't keep up and improve on what he had going for him in "" (8x06).



- Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)
Pros:
+  
The action sequence being surprisingly entertaining.
+  
Gigi taking a chance on Faith, despite Roden's disapproval.
  
Cons:
-  
Faith getting into the party just because she put up a fuss at the door.


- Quotes
FAITH:  
Anyway, live and learn. Almost die and learn way more.

WILLOW:  
(To Dawn) I swear, I'll un-embiggen you the second you tell me what incantation your significant other used while you two were... being significant together.

RODEN:  
See that lovely rack, fourth in line to meet Lady Geneviere? Keep an eye on her, would you, lads? Girl is making my wand tingle, and not in the good way.

WILLOW:  
(To Renee) First of all, what did we discuss about calling me by my mother's name?
RENEE:  
That I'd be turned into a baby goat if I didn't knock it off?
WILLOW:  
Very good, Renee, and please tell Ms. Summers that I already double-checked our perimeter's enchanted moat this morning.
RENEE:  
Actually, she said she was looking for, and I quote, "laptop-geek Willow, not broomstick-action Willow."


- Score Learn about the Grading Scale
86/100 B+
Just misses the mark of excellence. Essentially, a great episode that's rough around the edges and/or slightly flawed. Extremely fun to watch.


- Screencaps
<<Home
The Harvest>>

<<Season 7 Review
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

- Comments (2)

1.NixJan 16, 2008 (Wed)Link
If Faith calls herself `Charity' next, you'll know where `Hope' comes from. :)

2.AustinFeb 1, 2008 (Fri)Link
I was impressed that Faith held her character when she woke up and Gigi told her that they were different from everyone else and she said 'duh?' like 'of course were royalty' or at least lead Gigi to believe that was what she was saying. It was also really funny.


- Post a Comment
Name

(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.)
(*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***)

Security Code
Security Code

  

Copyright © 2010 CriticallyTouched.com, Mikelangelo Marinaro (e-mail me at: mikejer(at)criticallytouched(dot)com). All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of any review or article on this site is prohibited. All works and related characters are property of Joss Whedon, Mutant Enemy, 20th Century FOX, Universal Studios, Dark Horse Comics, and IDW Comics. I have no affiliation with Joss Whedon or any of those companies.