| [LIGHT | DARK] | NAVIGATE: ⇩ CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM |
|
| home | reviews | articles | links | discussion |
| Writer: | Dan Vebber |
| Director: | David Semel |
| - | Quick Links |
| - | Review |
If I have one complaint about S3, it's the lack of Spike. So when you mix S3's awesome consistency and great character development with Spike, you've got one hell of an episode. There is just so much fun to be had here that if there wasn't so much attention paid to the horrible Willow and Xander 'thing,' it would have gotten a perfect score. Thank the powers that this episode marks the end of that nonsense. Nonetheless, unlike some people I know, I don't let something minor ruin my appreciation for the rest of the episode.
The episode begins with the group getting their SAT scores back. Buffy gets a high score which shocks her into actually consider that she may have a life outside of slaying still, and the "college talk" begins. I like Joyce's discussion about it with Buffy at the house and how Buffy shoots down her mention of wanting keg parties and frat boys. Go Buffy! I think it's great that Giles actually encourages her to go to college and uses Faith as a possible way out. Angel even tells her, as a 'friend,' that she should leave Sunnydale and go to a good college. All of this just goes to show how much the people around Buffy genuinely care about her well-being and future.
For the rest of the episode, though, Spike steals the show. He rides into town again in the exact same way as in "School Hard" (2x03). He drives over the "Welcome to Sunnydale" sign again and will be the cause of it falling over one more time in the series finale, "Chosen" (7x22). He then visits Joyce just to chat with her about his breakup with Drusilla. His comment, "you got any of those little marshmallows?" gets me laughing every time.
All the great moments (many of which are captured in the quote section below) are attributed to Spike and his realizations. He admits he's "love's bitch" and explains to Buffy and Angel that they'll never be 'friends.' He says, "You're not friends. You'll never be friends. You'll be in love till it kills you both. You'll fight, and you'll shag, and you'll hate each other till it makes you quiver, but you'll never be friends." Spike is incredibly unhappy coming into this episode. He drinks a ton, which is always a sign of that (we saw him drinking a bunch while stuck in his wheelchair in "Surprise" [2x13]). All this sorrow stems from his love breaking up with him. Love is everything to Spike. Right now it's more a perverted love, but over the final three seasons of this series he begins to slowly change that perversion to purity and even ends up sacrificing his life ("Chosen" [7x22]) for love and redemption.
What's the one thing that brings Spike out of his sorrow? Violence. The moment he gets in a good brawl he feels himself again and leaves town in an attempt to get Dru back. Spike's powerful words obviously didn't go unnoticed to Buffy because she, soon afterwards, breaks it off with Angel realizing that they are not indeed 'friends' and that Angel can't give her the relationship she wants. If the Buffy and Angel relationship wasn't meant to end in "Faith, Hope, and Trick" (3x03) like I wanted, then this is the perfect cut-off point which is why I can't understand why they get all snuggly again later in the season, but that's another story.
The end of the episode shows everyone alone and unhappy, except for Spike who is back in form and singing while on the highway down south. This is a BtVS classic: it's got loads of humor, drama, messages, and action all in one tightly wrapped package. It's just a shame that I have to wait until S4 to get more Spike!
| - | Minor Pros/Cons (+/-) |
| Pros: | |
| + | Spike's hand catching on fire when he wakes up in the morning and having a really hard time getting into his car. Hilarious. |
| + | The Mayor is so weird and creepy. He is offering babies as sacrifice to a demon in "Band Candy" (3x06) while here he's playing mini golf in his office. |
| + | Xander's reference to Amy's backfired spell in "Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered" (2x16). |
| + | Spike mentions to Willow that Drusilla was making out with a Chaos Demon. We get to actually see this during a flashback in "Fool for Love" (5x07). |
| + | The funny faces Spike makes behind Joyce when Angel's stuck behind the vampire forcefield. |
| + | Joyce's confusion about what's going on after Buffy gets back. "Xander's a witch?" |
| + | Great fight sequence in the magic shop. |
| + | Cordelia death fake-out. |
| - | Foreshadowing |
|
| - | Quotes |
| OZ: | (to Willow) Well, I can see why you'd be upset. That was my sarcastic voice. |
| XANDER: | You know, it sounds a lot like your regular voice. |
| OZ: | I've been told that. |
| BUFFY: | I don't know. I guess... my future. I never really thought about it. I wasn't even sure I was going to have one. |
| CORDELIA: | Well, I think this is great! Now you can leave, and never come back! |
| WILLOW: | What's this? |
| OZ: | It's a gift. |
| WILLOW: | What's the occasion? |
| OZ: | Pretty much you are. |
| WILLOW: | (excited) It's a little, uh, PEZ witch! |
| OZ: | It's kind of a theme present. Do you like it? |
| WILLOW: | I like... I-I more than like. Oz, this is probably the sweetest... We have to find a little PEZ werewolf, so little PEZ witch can have a boyfriend. |
| OZ: | I don't think they make a werewolf PEZ. You might have to settle for a wacky cartoon dog. |
| JOYCE: | That's not it. It's just you belong at a, a good old-fashioned college with, with keg parties and boys, not here with Hellmouths and vampires. |
| BUFFY: | Not really seeing the distinction. |
| MAYOR: | Loose cannon. Rock the boat. Is that a mixed metaphor? |
| ALLAN: | (confused) Uh... |
| MAYOR: | Boats did have cannons. And a loose one would cause it to rock. Oh, honestly. I don't know where my mind goes these days. |
| SPIKE: | She wouldn't even kill me. She just left. She didn't even care enough to cut off my head or set me on fire. I mean, is that too much to ask? You know? Some little sign that she cared? |
| OZ: | It's Willow. She's nearby. |
| CORDELIA: | What? You can smell her? She doesn't even wear perfume. Oh, my God. Is this some sort of residual werewolf thing? This is very disturbing. |
| OZ: | I really agree. |
| ANGEL: | Buffy, we still need him to find the others. |
| BUFFY: | Need him? He's probably just got them locked up in the factory. |
| SPIKE: | Well, hey, how thick do you think I am? |
| : | ... |
| XANDER: | Where are we? |
| WILLOW: | The factory. We're locked in the basement. |
| SPIKE: | We killed a homeless man on this bench. Me and Dru. Those were good times. (chuckles) You know, he begged for mercy, and you know, that only made her bite harder. |
| BUFFY: | I guess you had to be there. |
| SPIKE: | I may be love's bitch, but at least I'm man enough to admit it. |
| - | Score | Learn about the Grading Scale |
| 95/100 |
A ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ |
A sharply written episode consisting of zero major mistakes. Usually develops characters in a meaningful manner and is a joy to watch on repeat viewings. Near perfect, but not quite there.
|
| - | Screencaps |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| - |
Comments (20)
|
| 1. | Clem's Kitten BasketDec 31, 2006 (Sun)Link | |
| This is my favourite episode of the series and I would give it a perfect score. I only have one tiny problem with it and that is the line(s) about baby food/supper during the fight in The Magic Box. Apart from that, nothing is wrong with this episode. Every character has wonderful lines, and there's not a scene that feels superfluous or wrong. Spike carries this episode, of course, but it's just perfect as a whole and it plays a significant part in every character's arc. The "thing" between Willow and Xander is very important and has to be played out. |
| 2. | AngelusJan 23, 2007 (Tue)Link | |
| I would have rated this perfect as well. This is one of the few episodes I will watch if I need a quick Buffy fix. |
| 3. | TranquillityFeb 15, 2007 (Thu)Link | |
| Love this episode! I think its the only time we ever see the Big 3 (Buffy, Spike and Angel) in action together. Something that with perhaps only ever happen now in comic book form [Bring on the comic books!!!!] The chemistry (acting and chemistry) between Buffy and Spike is palpable. The writers must have thought 'we've got to get those kids togethe!' |
| 4. | junMar 24, 2007 (Sat)Link | |
| More foreshadowing: Willow is all set to take the easy, dark arts way out of the problem of her and Xander's feelings for each other. This pattern continues through the forthcoming seasons. I hadn't realized before that her tendency to do this had begun quite so early. |
| 5. | robgnowApr 14, 2007 (Sat)Link | |
| I love James' line delivery when Spike is taunting Angel and throws out, "Your a very bad man." Just the way he says it while poor Joyce is utterly clueless is hilarious. |
| 6. | JessicaMay 1, 2007 (Tue)Link | |
| I agree, robgnow. I always crack a smile at that line;) |
| 7. | AustinSep 26, 2007 (Wed)Link | |
| I Love his pretending to bite her it's so great! He can never seem to get a good threat off, its great! He's always getting tasered, falling into graves, here he says you and what army and then Buffy is right there, throwing him down on the counter. |
| 8. | buffyholicOct 23, 2007 (Tue)Link | |
| Spike totally rules this episode, since the first scene to the last, he entertains and has a lot of great moments. I just love the tension between Buffy, Angel and him. And I also loved the scene with Willow, great tension. Another one of my favourite moments is Cordelia´s fake death and this is the first moment we really feel for her. |
| 9. | gabrielleabelleNov 8, 2007 (Thu)Link | |
| I adore this episode. Course, then we do have to wait till next season for more Spike. Oh well. Like somebody else pointed out, this is the first time we see Willow turn to magic to try to fix something instead of facing it herself. This, of course, continues and ends up sending her off the deep end in S6. It also shows how eerily Spike can see right through Buffy, which he also continues to do once he becomes a regular. Fav scene, hands down: When Spike is making faces at Angel behind Joyce's back. I nearly die laughing each time. |
| 10. | buffyfan14Apr 21, 2008 (Mon)Link | |
| i agree adore this episode and love seeing buffy, spike, and angel all together, but like others i dont like the language of babyfood that spike uses at the magic shop it makes the whole scene look stupid. Apart from that i think this is one of the best episodes and is definately in my top 10. |
| 11. | Michael CarruthersJul 18, 2008 (Fri)Link | |
| I agree completely on the review. This is a GREAT episode that seamlessly mixes heartbreaking drama and hilarious comedy, something the show is well-known for. Charisma Carpenter's scene in the hospital is so brilliantly acted and worth a mention I think. It's a very small line but she delivers it with a lot of power - "Xander?..Stay away from me." |
| 12. | SamNov 25, 2008 (Tue)Link | |
| I'd rate this as a Perfect. I think it was the first great episode since Becoming Pt 2. It also has one of the few lines that makes me laugh every single time I watch it, which is when Buffy says, "I guess you had to be there". Amazing episode, and it sets up new character arcs for the rest of the season [and beyond] very nicely. |
| 13. | EmilyMar 23, 2009 (Mon)Link | |
| I agree with Sam- I'd give this episode a P. |
| 14. | RosieJun 4, 2009 (Thu)Link | |
| It's interesting. This is the one episode that features Buffy, Spike and Angel as a fighting team . . . and they work well together. All three of them. |
| 15. | ChristianJun 9, 2009 (Tue)Link | |
| When I first saw this ep I thought Cordy was dead!! I rrally loved Buffy and Angel's conversation at the end. "What I want from you I can never have"... "Tell me you don't love me" It just shows how much frustration they both feel knowing they can't be together.. love it. |
| 16. | IdaJul 29, 2009 (Wed)Link | |
| Like many others here, I would have rated it P. I really like this episode, from start to end. |
| 17. | KateJul 31, 2009 (Fri)Link | |
| Honest, this is defnitely one of my favourites- but no suprise there, Spike is my favourite characters. His character arc is ultimately better than Buffy's and this is the first transition that starts to make him someone new. |
| 18. | MerryJun 13, 2010 (Sun) @ 3:21pmLink | |
| I don't think the Willow/Xander 'thing' should take points off this episode. One of the reasons this episode gets a P in my book is the fact that this is the episode where that silly 'thing' ends! |
| 19. | LizzieJun 30, 2010 (Wed) @ 3:09pmLink | |
| The scene where Spike tells Willow that they are gonna be best friends is sort of a fore-shadowing thing, cause they all kinda end up as, well, not friends, but, still... |
| 20. | jenskaJul 29, 2010 (Thu) @ 1:43pmLink | |
| Willow trying to hide the spell / spellbook from Xander? WIllow: "No no its chemistry!" bad girl. already knows magic is wrong when you do it against someones will, but she keeps on doing it all the way to Tabula Rasa where it rally bites her in the ass! |
| - | Post a Comment |
|
Name
(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.) (*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***) Security Code |