| [LIGHT | DARK] | NAVIGATE: ⇩ CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM |
|
| home | reviews | articles | links | discussion |
| Writer: | Marti Noxon |
| Director: | David Semel |
| - | Quick Links |
| - | Review |
This episode is a bit better than part one although it unfortunately retains many of that episode's poorer qualities including a slow pace, poor music, and mediocre fight sequences. This time around, though, Spike gets to interact with a lot of the main characters which creates a handful of good moments. Spike is the main thing that elevates this episode up a notch from the previous one.
Alright, we pick up right where the last one left us, with the discovery that Kendra is another Vampire Slayer and not the third Tarakan assassin. The conversation between Buffy and Kendra here is very entertaining and a good launching point for the episode. The scene moves into the library where Giles attempts to sort out what the heck is going on. It is during this scene that we find out how different Buffy and Kendra are, not only in personality but also in fighting methods and lifestyle. Kendra is the responsible "do it by the book" sort while Buffy is obviously the opposite. These differences are the beginning of all kinds of interesting discussing regarding the role of the Slayer, which method is better, and the possibility of Kendra replacing Buffy as 'the' Slayer.
The replacement issue in particular interests me a lot. By the end of this episode we find out that replacemnt won't work, so when Faith shows up in "Faith, Hope, and Trick" (3x03), nobody thinks about Faith replacing Buffy but instead think about Faith assissting her (aside from Joyce who didn't know all the Kendra issues). I also love Buffy's, "I could say, 'Kendra, you slay, I'm going to Disneyland.'" At this point in her life, that's really all Buffy wants. She would love to give up her Slayer powers and duty and just take off to Disneyland for a few months. If she knew what was going to happen soon in "Innocence" (2x14) she might better appreciate how decent things are in Sunnydale right now.
Unfortunately, I don't really like Kendra as a person very much. I like what her what her character does to contrast the uniqueness that Buffy possesses, but I find Kendra cold. Also, her accent is very grating and the acting behind her is mediocre. I do like how she mixes things up, though, and introduces an anomaly into the whole Slayer mythology.
A big development in this episode is the beginning of the Cordelia and Xander relationship. While I think their first kiss was ridiculously over-corned (and intentially too), the idea of the two of them together is oddly fascinating. Here's two people who have sparred from the very beginning of the series and now they have a 'thing' between then. They still mostly hate each other though. This is currently a completely physical attraction as these two have nothing in common. Only through time will they learn to actually care for each other. A few scenes in "Becoming Pt. 2" (2x22) come to mind as evidence of that.
The third Tarakan assassin, Patrice, was a breath of fresh air compared to the other two. Guns are very rarely used on this show, but I've got to admit they make things interesting. Buffy's fight with her in the school was satisfying. I also love Oz's, "I, uh, I'm shot! (takes his hand away briefly and chuckles) Y'know. (laughs) Wow! It's odd! And painful." The final fight scene with the assassins and Spike is handled okay, but it could have been much better in the hands of a better director (maybe he was just off his game that week). There are two things in particular, though, that really anger me. The first is that Patrice stops attacking Kendra so she can say her dumb line about that being her only shirt. The second, which surprised me, is the poor "I'm good!" line from Buffy. It's very rare this show completely gives into cliched dialog.
The episode ends on a high note, though, with Kendra explaining to Buffy that being the Slayer is who she is and not a job. I also found the very final shot, where a newly restored Drusilla picks Spike up out of the rubble of the church and slowly carries him out, very haunting. So when looking back at this two-parter as a whole I can't help but be disappointed. It wasn't bad, but it should be been a whole lot more. This second part is a bit better than the first, but it still has similar problems. Once again, though, there's a lot of great stuff mixed in as well.
| - | Minor Pros/Cons (+/-) |
| Pros: | |
| + | Love Xander spraying Cordelia with the hose even after she's running away. |
| + | I like the reference to the praying mantis in "Teacher's Pet" (1x04). |
| + | Buffy's protectiveness of Angel. |
| + | 43 churches in Sunnydale! |
| + | Angel using his knowledge of Drusilla in an attempt to make Spike angry enough to stake him before the ritual is done. |
| + | Kendra's entrance to the final fight. |
| + | Oz's "monkey pants" rant is great. |
| Cons: | |
| - | Kendra's shyness towards Xander is overdone. |
| - | Foreshadowing |
|
| - | Quotes |
| BUFFY: | I was only gone for a minute. |
| GILES: | Clearly it doesn't matter how long you were gone. You were physically dead! Thus causing the activation of the, the next Slayer. |
| KENDRA: | She died? |
| BUFFY: | Just a little! |
| WILLOW: | There's a Slayer handbook? |
| BUFFY: | Wait. Handbook? What handbook? How come I don't have a handbook? |
| WILLOW: | Is there a T-shirt, too? 'Cause that would be cool... |
| XANDER: | Angel's our friend! Except I don't like him. |
| OZ: | The monkey's the only cookie animal that gets to wear clothes, you know that? You have the sweetest smile I've ever seen. So, I'm wondering, do the other cookie animals feel sorta ripped? Like, is the hippo going, 'Hey, man, where are *my* pants? I have my hippo dignity!' And you know the monkey's just, (with a French accent) 'I mock you with my monkey pants!' And there's a big coup in the zoo. |
| WILLOW: | The monkey is French? |
| OZ: | All monkeys are French. You didn't know that? |
| - | Score |
| 75/100 | B- |
Flawed in some areas. Possibly lacking in character development and relevance or possessing a poor plot and/or villain. There's still a lot of good material mixed in with the mediocre.
|
| - | Screencaps |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| - | Comments (14) |
| 1. | buffyholicOct 13, 2007 (Sat) | |
| I like this episode better than the previous one, but I too get the impression that this could have been much better. I don´t like Kendra here, she annoys me a little and her accent is bad. But we have Oz, so major upside. And I love him with Willow, it´s so great. |
| 2. | Plain SimpleNov 12, 2007 (Mon) | |
| This could be a bit far fetched, but here we go: I once read that Whedon's original plan didn't have Oz leave in season 4 (that was done only because Seth Green got into movies), but it had Oz shot, like eventually Tara ended up being. So could Oz being shot in this episode have been meant as foreshadowing of his eventual demise, sort of book ending his life on the show by two shooting incidents? |
| 3. | Woohoo1729Dec 10, 2007 (Mon) | |
| That does sound a little far-fetched, though of course not completely dismissible. I think at the time Oz's getting shot was just a way to have one of the main characters become a casualty of the Order. Although that is interesting...what if Oz had stayed and got shot and drove Willow to the Dark Arts? hmm... I personally LOVED Kendra's character, including her accent. I'm pretty sure that since Prophecy Girl, upon original airing, this was the first episode that provided a real WOAH! moment. I was 12 at the time, and after the cliffhanger moment from the last episode, I went to class the next day and could not stop talking about the possibility of a second slayer with my fellow Buffy-fanatic friend. Ah, the memories... |
| 4. | JadenJul 15, 2008 (Tue) | |
| if patrice had shot oz fatally we could have done the dark willow arc right now! |
| 5. | spateswifeAug 19, 2008 (Tue) | |
| Did ANYBODY notice that at the end when Angel and Drusilla are separated (they were joined by being stabbed through the hands)that Angel had no hole/stab wound in his hand? Big goof there. Also what I find amusing is that in my hometown of Bay City, TX there are also 43+ churches in town!!! I always knew there was a hell mouth there. That town is nothing but EVIL!!! |
| 6. | LeeluFeb 12, 2009 (Thu) | |
| @spateswife:
Nah, that's just part of being in the South. haha I know, I'm from the Coast in Mississippi. There is a damned church on every freaking block, pretty much. And the Coast is on the outskirts of the Bible Belt. It's much worse when you get deeper into the Bible Belt a little more north, like around Hattiesburg, etc. |
| 7. | EmilyFeb 16, 2009 (Mon) | |
| It's known that Kendra is the opposite of Buffy in every way, but it's interesting to note that Buffy came to Sunnydale to get away from her destiny, from what happened in LA. And when in Angel tells her he knows she wants to "kill them all," she responds with, basically, a NO. And Kendra, as the opposite of Buffy, says the following: "To do my duty- I am here to kill vampires."
It's incredibly ironic that Spike has so much money here, as opposed to the later seasons where he'll do anything for a quick buck. Do the effects of the sun make a vampire weak? Like if they were indirectly exposed to it, like Angel was here. I don't remember that ever happening before or after in Buffy. Or was it because he hadn't had any blood in a while? I think that when Kendra tells Buffy, "It's not a job- it's who you are," Buffy actually does internalize that. I think we see- not right away, of course, it's more gradual- but we see Buffy actually become the slayer, as opposed to just doing the job of a slayer. And I think that also partly has to do with Angel becoming Angelus, and her subsequent growing-upness. If Buffy has equal or greater power than vampires, shouldn't she have been able to pick up Angel by herself, without Kendra's help, like Dru picked up Angel? Or were the writers trying to show Kendra's acceptance of Angel as a good guy? I love the beginning of Oz and Willow's relationship. I love Tara, don't get me wrong, but Oz is the be-all and end-all of sweet, fun-sized boyfriends. Mike, maybe I'm missing something, but I don't understand why Kendra wasn't able to replace Buffy in the end. Obviously, to keep the show going, but I don't think the writers even mentioned it at all when Buffy was seeing Kendra off. Personally, I don't understand how anyone could like Buffy with anyone but Angel after that scene in the church when she kneels down next to him. The Scoobies just stare in awe at the beauty of that scene- how could you ever dismiss something like that? For Scott? Ewwwww. For Riley? Ewwwwww. For Spike? I could see where you're going with that, but not really. No one's ever gonna be Angel. (And there's my episodic Bangel rant lol.) All in all, I love this episode. I understand why you would give it a B-, but I would give it at least an A-. |
| 8. | RosieApr 13, 2009 (Mon) | |
| It's interesting that Kendra was taught that having family and friends detract from the Slayer calling. Those are the very same qualities that keep Buffy alive for so long, which Spike points out to her in "Fool for Love" (5x07). They are also the people that bring her back to life in "Bargaining Pt. 1" (6x01). It's Buffy family and friends that make her such a strong Slayer.
I DISAGREE. What made Buffy a strong Slayer was that she did things her way. What made Kendra a strong Slayer was that she did things her way - namely going by the book. When Kendra tried to do things the Buffy way at the end of Season 2, she got killed. |
| 9. | RosieApr 13, 2009 (Mon) | |
| Mike, maybe I'm missing something, but I don't understand why Kendra wasn't able to replace Buffy in the end. Obviously, to keep the show going, but I don't think the writers even mentioned it at all when Buffy was seeing Kendra off.
Kendra DID replace Buffy. She became the Slayer. The Slayer line passed through her between Season 1's "Prophecy Girl" and "Becoming". Buffy has never been THE SLAYER since "Prophecy Girl". For some reason, fans find this hard to accept. |
| 10. | EmilyMay 11, 2009 (Mon) | |
| Rosie, I don't mean in terms of the prophecy. I'm talking about the inconsistencies of the writers- they didn't give a reason why Buffy had to stay and be the slayer. They brought this whole thing up when talking about how she could be the slayer instead of Buffy and Buffy would have a normal life. But at the end, Kendra leaves. I understand that this is a show about *Buffy* the Vampire Slayer, but they didn't work it into the episode. |
| 11. | AndrewJun 6, 2009 (Sat) | |
| Exactly, Rosie. When Kendra died, Faith was created. Buffy is the freaky offshoot, which of course goes with part of the point of the show - Buffy is different from all the rest, which makes her story worth chronicaling. |
| 12. | SunburnSep 18, 2009 (Fri) | |
| I love Kendra's accent! We were discussing it last night... it's a hilarious combination of Jamaican, American and, for some reason, Irish. LOL. "It's interesting that Kendra was taught that having family and friends detract from the Slayer calling." I agree. I suppose it fits with the idea of the lone assassin, without any vulnerabilities which could be used to hurt or blackmail her. For some reason, it made me think of the prohibition on gays in the military; the argument against, I thought, was that it would affect battlefield performance negatively, but for me, it's always seemed that if it had any effect at all it would more likely provoke acts of heroism. In my head, that connects with the heroism of all the Scoobies at times, and of Buffy's in protecting them, but I understand that my connection might seem like bollocks to everyone else. :-D Emily: "Personally, I don't understand how anyone could like Buffy with anyone but Angel after that scene in the church when she kneels down next to him. [...] Spike? I could see where you're going with that, but not really. No one's ever gonna be Angel." Can't help but bite on this one! OK, for me, that scene was adorable, and when I first watched the series, I was very sad when Angel left at the end of season 3. But Spuffy had the potential for something more, IMO. I wish the AR hadn't happened, because it kind of made a relationship between them impossible. But if we're talking moments between them, the trusting moments in season 7 went far beyond this one with Angel because of everything they'd been through together. And for me, the snarky, funny, down-to-earth Spike would be endlessly better fun than the tediously brooding Angel. So much has been made of Spike being 'love's bitch'; even the terminology is demeaning, hence the horror with which everyone regards it. I personally think that as people, relationships are the most important things in our lives, and since Spike, as a vampire, had a lot less to worry about in terms of careers, children and settling down, prioritising love over everything else was not just what made him happy but actually sensible and logical too. |
| 13. | ZapheNov 14, 2009 (Sat) @ 10:42pm | |
| I totally agree with Sunburn, the thing I admire in Spuffy is that Spike had went through the trouble to obtain a soul for her, he went through the pain and torture to break down the barrier between him and Buffy where Angel just accepted the situation. All through Buffy and Angel episodes, it never showed he actively try to seek a solution to the impossible situation between him and Buffy. If Buffy is his only love for 200 years, doesn't it worth his while to try. Perhaps he can go and try to seek the legend and earn his soul so that he would not be a human and cant help Buffy fight like he claimed in Angel series "I will rememeber you".
The fact that Spike fought for his soul to be worthy of Buffy, allows that he can fight by her side and rooms for a relationship. It's been shown all through Season 7 how much they trusted and relied on each other and formed such a strong team. I believe that if he hadn't died in then end, Spuffy will get together again. As to AR, I think Buffy got over it by sleeping with him for 3 nights (though no sex) and I think deep down she knows that Spike is not a rapist and that happened before he had a soul and lack of moral compass. |
| 14. | AJDFeb 12, 2010 (Fri) @ 4:33pm | |
| Just re-watched these episodes. Kendra's accent is DREADFUL and distracting! If the character really, really had to be Jamaican then why not either a) hire a Jamaican actress to play the part, or b) hire an actress who can do a Jamaican accent properly! Or simply make Kendra American and let the poor girl speak normally! I kept expecting her to tuck into a pint of Guinness... That's my only gripe. I bet Bianca cringes when she looks back! |
| - | Post a Comment |
|
Name
(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.) (*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***) Security Code |