| [LIGHT | DARK] | NAVIGATE: ⇩ CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM |
|
| home | reviews | articles | links | discussion |
| Writer: | Carl Ellsworth |
| Director: | Bruce Seth Green |
| - | Quick Links |
| - | Review |
Here we have humor and action deftly woven together to create an absolutely wonderful episode. The only complaint I have is that at the end, when Buffy becomes herself again, she knocks Spike on the floor and lets him run away without any effort to keep him trapped. She could have beaten him to a bloody pulp until someone got her a stake. Aside from that, though, there is much fun to be had here!
The episode begins with a vampire filming Buffy, with a video camera, fighting a different vampire. We soon discover that this video is meant for Spike. He is studying the Slayer in even more detail, preparing for their next encounter. Not only is it great seeing Spike checking her out like this, but James Marsters has this uncanny ability to hold your attention when he's on screen. Spike is just such a fun character to watch, regardless of the plot. Juliet Landau doesn't slouch either as Drusilla. She manages to convey this sense of extreme helplessness and utter creepiness at the exact same time. How that is possible I do not know.
I'd like to quickly mention that I really appreciate the continuity of the smaller stuff, like Devon checking out Cordelia in "Inca Mummy Girl" (2x04), so now they're trying to date (Devon doesn't show up). A little more significant in plot is Buffy and Angel trying to meet for coffee. The entire last episode dealt with the fact that Angel didn't want to get together with Buffy for a coffee. It's just really refreshing to see this stuff remembered and built upon.
Anyway, I enjoyed seeing Buffy wondering if Angel would prefer she were a noble woman from his time. This naturally leads to the scene in Ethan's costume shop where she goes all wide-eyed and cute over the pink princess dress. She gets the dress from Ethan Rayne, who casts a spell to turn people into their costumes. It is really cool seeing what everyone thinks of the new, helpless, Buffy. Cordelia says it best by saying, "what's that riff?" Everyone else is pretty confused by her transformation except for Willow who gets to take charge of the situation all by herself.
Willow gets a ton of character development here. She finally gets a big dose of self confidence, which is an important step in her ongoing journey to becoming a very powerful individual. She hides her skimpy outfit out of shyness but then, post-spell, is forced to walk around in it. Until Giles asked her "the ghost of what?" she hadn't even noticed that she looked all skimpy. This goes to show that when things get out of hand and Buffy's not around to take charge, she has it in her to take command and acheive that self-confidence.
The whole concept of this plot is just really fun. A lot of roles get to reverse and all the characters are stronger for it. As mentioned before, Willow gets to take charge, but Buffy becomes the opposite: helpless. Seeing Buffy that pretrified is very new, and of course Spike loves it. Xander also gets in the action, literally this time, and just all around kicks ass. He beats up Larry to protect Buffy when earlier in the episdode Buffy protected Xander from Larry. Xander's "beating up that pirate gave me a weird sense of closure" is a hoot. Giles also gets some development which is a result of his dialog with Ethan. We find out that they know each other and that Giles has quite the unsavory past. This adds some intrigue and depth to a character that was hanging around the two-dimensional mark.
Overall there is a ton of good stuff in here. Lots of subtle and not-so subtle character development mixed with a fun plot and great acting. This is a very fun episode to watch and new people who are just getting into the show always love it. I'm right there with them, this is a great stuff.
| - | Minor Pros/Cons (+/-) |
| Pros: | |
| + | Snyder forcing people to 'volunteer' taking groups of kids out for Halloween. |
| + | Buffy stomping on the "guy code" when preventing Xander from getting pummelled by Larry. I also like how the diet pop comes out of the machine for Buffy. |
| + | The entire scene where Buffy distracts Giles so Willow can sneak into his office and borrow his private books on Angel. I especially like it when Buffy blurts out "Jenny thinks you're a babe!" Willow then shakes her head right to left saying 'bad girl' without words. |
| + | Cordelia's comment about being the 'dating Slayer' actually scaring Buffy a bit. |
| + | Oz stumbling into Willow in her ghost costume. |
| + | I adore the scene where Willow walks through the wall into the library and freaks Giles out. |
| + | Creepy face/eyes shot of Giles at the end. |
| - | Foreshadowing |
|
| - | Quotes |
| BUFFY: | Dates are things normal girls have. Girls who have time to think about nail polish and facials. You know what I think about? Ambush tactics. Beheading. Not exactly the stuff dreams are made of. |
| BUFFY: | Angel's a vampire. I thought you knew. |
| CORDELIA: | Oh, he's a vampire. Of course! But the cuddly kind. Like a Carebear with fangs? |
| XANDER: | Hello! That was our touching reconciliation moment there. |
| XANDER: | Whoa! She must be right. We must have some kind of amnesia. |
| BUFFY: | I don't know what that is, but I'm certain I don't have it. I bathe quite often! |
| GILES: | Janus. Roman mythical god. |
| WILLOW: | What does this mean? |
| GILES: | Primarily the division of self. Male and female, light and dark. |
| ETHAN: | Chunky and creamy. Oh, no, sorry, that's peanut butter. |
| - | Score |
| 95/100 | A |
A sharply written episode consisting of zero major mistakes. Usually develops characters in a meaningful manner and is a joy to watch on repeat viewings. Near perfect, but not quite there.
|
| - | Screencaps |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| - | Comments (22) |
| 1. | junAug 9, 2006 (Wed) | |
| I thought that Devon and Cordelia actually /were/ dating in "Inca Mummy Girl". She certainly blathers on about how she'll not be right by the stage while being right by the stage. :) |
| 2. | AthenaMuzeAug 24, 2006 (Thu) | |
| I know this is all the way back in S2, but I was catching up on some reviews and I happened to have the chance to watch the episode recently. I noticed a few things I thought were interesting in the continuity/foreshadowing realm of this episode that were not mentioned in the review. 1. Honey I'm home: This is what Buffy says to Spike when she returns to herself and then starts beating the crap out of him. In S7, after Buffy retrieves the scythe and returns to the house, Spike comes in the door saying "Honey you're home" 2. The dress: specifically the sketch of the dress in the watcher's journal. Is it just me, or does this getup resemble some of the early Darla looks? 3. Of course the obvious: Xander retains his knowledge of the military for quite some time after this event and this is referred to several times throughout the series. Some of it may be trivial or coincidence, but still interesting I thought... |
| 3. | mikejerAug 24, 2006 (Thu) | |
| Generally I try not to put too much of what is considered 'continuity' in the foreshadowing section, and will touch on it in the review that the continuity appears in. So out of your three points, I'd classify the first one as having the most relevance in that particular section of the episode. That's a very fun little connection! If anything, it may foreshadow the eventual relationship between them. Cool stuff though. :) |
| 4. | jessicaApr 9, 2007 (Mon) | |
| hi this is me again this is a good episode i liked it when buffy said i like the man with a musket do you have a musket :L:L:L: lol |
| 5. | LatoyaMay 22, 2007 (Tue) | |
| I do not like Willow being the leader. It just doesn't come off as natural to me. Not here, and definitely not in those few eps in season 5 & 6 when Buffy was temporarily gone and she took over. Wilow comes off a little forced. Very scary in the later seasons since you can see that hint of evil from all of the magics. Such as when she separated Xander and Spike after Buffy went into catatonia. Or when she was using her telepathy on the group in Bargaiing against their will. |
| 6. | NinaJun 21, 2007 (Thu) | |
| i love willow being the leader! shes just way to cool. I was watching the episode and i was all "FUCK look at angels face when buffy screams when he turns into a vampire!" like.. imagin if you were angel and your soon to be girlfriend screamed at you! but yeah. im a weirdo.. and only weirdoz think about this kinda stuff! Love this epy. Ninaa |
| 7. | MelanieJun 26, 2007 (Tue) | |
| Buffy's reaction to seeing a car for the first time, "It's a demon!" This is the exact same response Angel will have when he looses his memory and sees LA traffic speeding by in the "Angel" episode "Spin the Bottle." |
| 8. | SunnyJul 29, 2007 (Sun) | |
| I love how Cordelia hangs all over Angel, and Willow goes 'he'd never fall for her act' and lo and behold... a few seasons later, an a spin off show, and Willow is proved very wrong. Ahaha, the security code was 'wusp', that makes me laugh... it's 4 in the morning, I'm easily amused... |
| 9. | buffyholicOct 10, 2007 (Wed) | |
| I agree with Nina, I also think that Willow as a leader is vey cool and it seems very natural to me. I really like when she freaks Giles and then he says "the ghost of what?". Very good episode, excellent episode. And I also like Giles as a badass. |
| 10. | gabrielleabelleNov 6, 2007 (Tue) | |
| I tend to think of Willow as a fairly good leader. She's got the smarts, she just lacks the confidence. In the early seasons, we see her get past that every now and again (this episode being an example), but we also see later on what happens when she gets a bit too much confidence and goes overboard. Love this ep. It's such a classic. |
| 11. | EmilyFeb 15, 2009 (Sun) | |
| I just wanted to point out that I really like the way Angel says, "Simpering morons, the lot of them." That was funny, especially when you compare it to the way he described the gypsy girl in 1x07: "beautiful...dumb as a post."
I also think that you missed out on a pro, Mike: at the end, when Willow walks around in her skimpy outfit and Oz continues to wonder who she is. I like the continuity- I think this line means that he's been trying to figure out who she is since "Inca Mummy Girl" and still hasn't found out her name. Also, I love how Cordelia doesn't believe Buffy when she and Willow tell her that Angel's a vampire! Nina, I agree- I kinda felt bad for Angel when Buffy screamed in fright. And Sunny, when Angel falls in love with Cordelia, she's a very different person....I think the point there is that Cordelia doesn't have an "act" anymore. Her character grows in leaps and bounds in AtS. (Not that I approve in any way of Buffy or Angel being with other people besides each other. Except maybe Spike when I'm in the middle of watching Season 6 or 7.) All in all, amazing episode. One of my favorites. |
| 12. | SamMar 28, 2009 (Sat) | |
| Cordelia has all the best lines in this episode: "Buffy, love the hair. It just screams street urchin." "Look, Buffy. You may be hot stuff when it comes to demonology or whatever, but when it comes to dating, I'm the Slayer." Willow: Okay, your name is Cordelia, you're not a cat, you're in high school and we're your friends... well, sort of. Cordelia: That's nice, Willow, and you went mental when?? Willow: You know us? Cordelia: Yeah, lucky me. Buffy: Well, it's not our place to fight. Surely some men will protect us! Cordelia: What's THAT riff? "They don't know who they are, everyone's turned into a monster, it's a WHOLE big thing. How are you?" (The lights go out and Buffy gets scared and clings to Cordelia) Cordelia: Do you mind? |
| 13. | SamMar 28, 2009 (Sat) | |
| This episode also gets bonus points for finally letting Alyson Hannigan show off how pretty she is |
| 14. | buffbotApr 26, 2009 (Sun) | |
| ehh see when buffy and willow are in the bathroom looking at the book of angels past is the girl in the dress darla that they discuss |
| 15. | EmilyMay 11, 2009 (Mon) | |
| Buffbot, I think it's Dru. |
| 16. | SeleneJul 6, 2009 (Mon) | |
| I lve when Giles flips out when Willow walks through the wall and think Willow's frustrated "She couldn't have dressed up like Xena?" was hilarious.
Willow as a leader is a great thing as not only does she have the smarts, she takes the time to use them. She doesn't go running off half-cocked. And the Ripper/Ethan scene was superb! Oh, Giles, you naughty boy, what did you get up t in the past? |
| 17. | LucyAug 6, 2009 (Thu) | |
| I did love this episode, except for the fact that Buffy tries to dress Willow up as a normal teenager for Halloween. Aren't people supposed to wear fancy dress costumes? They could at least have got her a sexy demon outfit or a witch (that would have been cool for the continuity) but her costume is just Buffy's normal clothes. Just seemed slightly weak to me. Still one of my favourite episodes though-I love Ethan Rayne! |
| 18. | NixSep 14, 2009 (Mon) | |
| Emily, it can't be Dru: Angel never met Dru until after he was vamped. The entry is labelled 'Sarah Crockford' (or something like that), so I think we must assume it's just some random upper-class girl we never heard of. |
| 19. | PersonNov 16, 2009 (Mon) @ 7:18pm | |
| Adorable! XD
The "Who IS that girl!?" line is classic. Kinda like Cinderella, only Oz never really got to meet Willow before that line (well, he attempted!) and he has like, no artifact other than look for the cute little red head tagging along a blonde, a geek and the school librarian. |
| 20. | EmilyNov 26, 2009 (Thu) @ 10:12pm | |
| Nix, I just realized that it's impossible for it to be Dru because they were saying that it was 1775 and he was 18. Never caught that till now. |
| 21. | Smallprint84Mar 7, 2010 (Sun) @ 8:00pm | |
| And I noticed last week some more foreshadowing/continuity: When Xander takes his shirt off and is shown in his military green undershirt, Cordelia is quite impressed by his body. This later happens again in S2 - Go Fish. |
| 22. | Smallprint84Mar 7, 2010 (Sun) @ 8:00pm | |
| When they are dating. |
| - | Post a Comment |
|
Name
(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.) (*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***) Security Code |