Angel  > ReviewsArticlesFeaturesLinks
1x15: "The Prodigal"
Review by Ryan Bovay (Ryan-R.B.)
Posted on May 14, 2006
Writer: Tim Minear | Director: Bruce Seth Green | Air Date: 02/22/2000

Quick Links
Spoiler Warning!
This is a retrospective review and may contain spoilers from anywhere in the series. Read at your own peril.
Review

If C-rate sitcoms, B-rate rom-coms and every quasi-humorous advertisements featuring two young people on a date have taught us anything, it's that fathers are protective of their daughters. Above sons and wives, a father places his daughter on a pedestal. The poet Joseph Addison gave me one of my very favourite thoughts on these differences when he said: "In love to our wives there is desire; to our sons, ambition; but to our daughters there is something which there are no words to express." "The Prodigal," aside from some interesting points and a load of important back-story on Angel, is about fathers, sons and daughters, and how all these bonds play their parts.

It's also extremely important in the long run of the show, not just for the history on Angel, but because it establishes some of the most important parts of the mythology concerning vampires in the Whedonverse. Up to this point, they've functioned as sexual metaphors and A Class villains, but here we get a deeper and essential understanding of their functions as creatures; how they relate to one another. More on that later, though. The first of the episode's two plotlines focuses on Angel, or more specifically Liam (as he was named in human life), who we finally get some real answers on. Up to this point we've only seen flashes of his past in BtVS and in "Somnambulist" [1x11]; here we get a dollop's more of important history.

Liam lived life a drunken wastrel, fraternizing endlessly with town women, squandering and taking for granted every opportunity and advantage given to him by his (perceivably) wealthy family's life. Ashamed of by his father, Liam is a man driven to his useless life by his weaknesses and his failings in his fathers eyes. I was reminded of Jared Leto's character in the feature film 'Lord of War,' where he played the brother and co-conspirator of a gunrunner who turned to cocaine and prostitutes when the reality of the evil he was purporting became too much for him to handle. Liam is much the same in how he turns to debauchery in part to spite his father, but it's really more of a giving in, as he's unable to please the man he truly cares for, but cannot express love for.

Likewise, his father does care for his son. When Liam decides to leave, he has fear for his only boy, and worries. But the distance between them has left him unable to express it, and he can deal with his son only in anger and fear, for fear his actions will take Liam down a terrible road which, eventually, they do. This is where the extremely well drawn parallel to Kate and her father Trevor is made; both fathers, for their own reasons, are far from their children. We learned in "Sense and Sensitivity" [1x06] that Trevor Lockley became an emotional void after the death of his wife and became unable to express love for his daughter. Neither of the two men can communicate properly with their children despite love, and this leads to the downfall of both.

Also tying the two threads together is the present day Angel. The largest part that makes this episode so significant is that we finally learn exactly why he feels as responsible as he does for all the crimes of Angelus. One could argue, quite potently, that by lacking a soul he was not in charge of his own will and was more like an animal; he's not consciously responsible. That's not entirely so. The truth of Liam's actions is that he is, if indirectly, responsible for the demon that emerged from the grave that night at Darla's side. His debauchery, and more importantly, his ignorance of the dangers around him, brought him to his end at his own fault.

It's exactly why he understands Trevor's situation, even if his was the moral opposite. "Sometimes the price we end up paying for one bad choice isn't commensurate with the offence," Angel tells Wesley. Living for a hundred years with the guilt of what may have been thousands of murders on one's hands is hardly a balanced punishment for being a drunken wastrel. Nor is death a fit sentence for Trevor's sins, given that his motives were noble, even though like Liam his motivations drove him beyond practical consideration. In one way or another it was still his fault, like it was Angel's; how this sequence of events unfolded was masterful. Writer Tim Minear is near the top of his game here.

Now, as for the mythological: we're given some more information on the nature of vampires, things that will be very important in the coming seasons of Angel and, to a lesser extent, Buffy. Aside from the further sexualization of vampires (Liam rising from the grave and coming into a new world of senses and pleasures; puberty), we're given two things: A vampire's rising is treated by their sire as a birth. Also, they often view the new vampire as both a companion (which is why most vampires are sired by the opposite sex) and a child; a child to be taught and brought up in this new and amazing world of the night.

This was done solely to fit with the story and it made a good counterpoint, as Angelus had everything Liam/Angel did not in a parental figure. And this is where, even if unintentionally, the writers are giving us the most important key to a vampire's personality: defiance. In life, Angel was a drunken (chalk up more points for another use of this word, please) artless waste, looked down upon by his father for his uselessness. As Angelus, he was the constant delight of Darla, his 'mother,' and took his obsession with mental agony to frightening and artistic levels. Based on this, one can actually have a good psychological look at most vampires and imagine what they were in life.

I guess they did something right here, as the canon of both Buffy and Angel does incorporate this as fact, and continues establishing it, too. BtVS "Fool for Love" (5x07) shows Spike as a human by the name of William Pratt (nice joke, "pratt" being English slang for annoying and all), a mediocre, unppreciated man who was seen as someone to be laughed at. Upon becoming a vampire he strove to be nothing but the fastest, most feared, most extraordinary and notorious force in the field that he inhabited. In this case, it happened to be terror and death, and lord, did he excel. Even Drusilla, our hints about her past comparably few, took to pure coldness and evil, having been a puritan and holy woman in life.

My last thoughts lie with Addison's words. What is a daughter to a father? It's not the most relevant quote to the episode but I really enjoy the truth it invokes about parents and children. Trevor and Liam's father were both deeply loving of their children, but one could say that Trevor is much more unconditional and with a lot of proof, too. At times, he's expressed clear disappointment for Kate. Several times in fact, in "Sense and Sensitivity" [1x06]. Yet it plays no part in his feelings for his daughter, and it's nice to learn here that despite his regrettable fate, all he was, was for her.

Liam's father, despite it all, still played to Addison's tune. Men hold ambitions for their sons, more directly relatable to them, and a large part of his distance from Liam was due to how he failed in every one of his expectations. He couldn't be close as a result of this, no matter how much he may have wanted to be. Trevor's distance from Kate, on the other hand, was purely because of an emotional circumstance (the death of his wife), and this does speak volumes about the differences between these relationships.

As an experience, "The Prodigal" was unique. Not quite the best in the season, it still holds a great note of balance between heart, development, significance and entertainment, a macabre mix similar in tone to few other episodes. This too is just a shadow of the dark, complex greatness Tim Minear is to offer us in the future, as he would go on to write "Darla" [2x07], "Epiphany" [2x16] and "That Old Gang of Mine" [3x03], among many fantastic others. He'd already written the Perfect "Somnambulist" [1x11] by this point too. It has everything you could want from this type of show, and, oh, some really snappy dialogue to boot.

Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)
+Angel's birthname was Liam, which is the Irish equivalent of William. Ha!
+Trevor thinking Angel was gay. This is the second use of this to-be long running joke.
+Angelus rising from his grave. This was wholly chilling, knowing everything he would go on to do.
+"Plan B."
+Wrist mounted stakes, again!
  
-When Angelus gets out of his grave, you can see both his and Darla's breath. Vampires don't breathe.
Foreshadowing
  • Kate tells Angel of their relationship "I'm not sure it does (work)." From this episode on their bond is frail, and never heals. What little trust she had of Angel is now shattered and they never again really "work," at times even coming into direct conflict with each other ("To Shanshu in LA" [1x22]).
  • After her father's death, Kate sets herself stone-faced against the vampires and the demon. From this episode on, she focuses her interest in the underworld, and her furious attitude towards all of it becomes her entire demeanor in all of her life, as seen in "The Thin Dead Line" [2x14].
95/100A
N/A

DEPTH
N/A

EMOTION
N/A

CHARACTER
N/A

PLOT
Quotes
ANGEL:It's being taken care of. It's just that the ah, evil thing - turns out it wasn't an *evil* thing.
KATE:The evil thing wasn't an evil thing?
ANGEL:Well, it was an evil thing in terms of that word. It just wasn't an evil evil thing.
KATE:There are not evil evil things?
ANGEL:Well – yeah

LIAM:As you wish, father. Always, *just* as you wish.
FATHER:It's a son I wished for – a man – instead God gave me you! A terrible disappointment.
LIAM:Disappointment? A more dutiful son you couldn't have asked for. My whole life you've told me in word, in glance, what it is you required of me, and I've lived down to your every expectations, now haven't I?
FATHER:That's madness
LIAM:No. The madness is that I couldn't fail enough for you. But we'll fix that now, won't we?

VAMPIRE:Any instructions on how we should deal with this Angel person, sir?
DEMON:Kill him.
VAMPIRE:Sure that would be wise, Sir? Lockley appears to be growing uncomfortable with our arrangement as it is. Sudden death of this private investigator could turn him...
DEMON:Kill Lockley, too. God, do I have to think of everything around here?

ANGELUS:Strange - Somehow you seemed taller when I was alive.
FATHER:Lord, bind this demon now.
ANGELUS:To think I ever let such a tiny, trembling thing make me feel the way you did.
FATHER:(makes sign of the cross) I pray ye, give me your protection, Father.
ANGELUS:You told me I wasn't a man. (Slowly stalks closer to his dad) You told me I was nothing – and I believed you. You said I'd never amount to anything. Well, you were wrong. (Morphs to Vampire face) You see, father? I have made something out of myself after all.

WESLEY:What happened to calmly, cautiously, and deliberately investigating before rushing in?
ANGEL:That was plan A. We've since moved on to plan B.
WESLEY:And plan B is?
ANGEL:(turns around, twirling huge fighting axe) Do I really have to explain it to you, Wesley?
WESLEY:No.

DARLA:(about Liam's father) Your victory over him took but moments. But his defeat of you will last life times.
ANGELUS:What are you talking about? He can't defeat me now.
DARLA:Nor can he ever approve of you – in this world or any other. What we once were informs all that we have become. The same love will infect our hearts – even if they no longer beat. Simple death won't change that.
ANGELUS:Love? - Is this the work of love?
DARLA:(smiles) Darling boy. So young. Still so very young.


Comments (18)
All Comments | Link1 | TranquillityMar 10, 2007
A really good episode. I love any episode with a hint of backstory and this one was a ripper. So much about what makes angel tick is revealed in the flashback scenes making it an episode of considerable significance.
All Comments | Link2 | Ryan-R.B. | WRITERMar 10, 2007
It's an episode that has more layers the more times you've seen it. I find something new I like every time. I was very torn on whether or not to award it the 'Most Important' award of the season over 'Shanshu,' but I think it earns it. One ingredient necessary for a successful spinoff is a character whose story isn't done being told in the original show, and it's where we start getting deep into Angel's past and learning a lot of new stuff. This set the trend for episodes like "Darla" in that way. So, it's pretty important.
All Comments | Link3 | buffyholicFeb 5, 2008
This episode is really outstanding. It has flashbacks concerning Angelus and Darla that I always love and has something new everytime I see it.
All Comments | Link4 | EmilyMay 10, 2009
I just wanted to point out that I think it's really interesting that it was his sister who gave Liam the name "Angel." Yeah, we've seen that his name was Angelus because he was the demon with the face of an angel, but it seems here that it came from his sister. Who, by the way, I felt really bad for because she loved her older brother so much.



I also really liked the part in the flashback when Liam told his father: "Out of my way," and his father grabs him, with this sad, heart-wrenching look in his eyes, and says, "I was never in your way, boy."
All Comments | Link5 | wytchcroftAug 1, 2009
Yep, it don't do nothing but ROCK.
All Comments | Link6 | ArouetAug 8, 2009
Stylistically this is also a hugely important episode because it marks the first use of the juxtaposition of (usually past and present) events for the sake of reinforcing a theme. It's this episode that leads to Five by Five, Darla, and Deep Down.
All Comments | Link7 | SeánSep 17, 2010 @ 5:23pm
This IS an outstanding episode and it's always interesting to get more of Angel's backstory. But Ryan, out of respect for your Irish readers (such as myself), I would like if you put in the minor cons section, the terrible "top o' the mornin'" Irish accents done here. Honestly if you were from Ireland, you would just realise how horribly cringeworthy David Boreneaz and all the other 'Irish' characters accents are here!
All Comments | Link8 | nathan.taurusJan 10, 2011 @ 10:09pm
Good:
-Olden time Liam. Christina Hendricks as a bar maid (Saffron from 'Firefly')(Mad Men)
-Liam's father seems nice. Liam seems the dumb-arse.
-Angelus takes out his family and pauses at the recollection of his sister thinking he was an angel.
-Trevor asking if Angel's from 'West Hollywood'. With a name like Angel, good question.
-Darla telling him he hasn't won as his father can never approve of him.
Bad:
-When Kate kneels down to her father, he blinks......he is dead. Ah, zombie.
-Angelus and Darla breathing in the cold air.

Trivia: The bland tomestones have "Beloved Son" and "Beloved Father".
All Comments | Link9 | Rob W.Sep 27, 2012 @ 4:36pm
Virgin soil? In LA?
All Comments | Link10 | DaveNov 8, 2012 @ 12:17am
I'd take "Vampires don't breathe" off of the cons. They do breath, Angel's faux pas in BtVS season 1 was exactly that. They breathe to speak and out of habit.
All Comments | Link11 | DaveNov 8, 2012 @ 12:37am
Also wanted to add a personal pro: Angel watching Kate at the cemetery reminded me of, or rather it may have been the other way around, Joyce's death and Angel showing up there. I can't remember, I didn't watch them chronologically.
All Comments | Link12 | NearlySaneApr 8, 2013 @ 12:19am
Just to note that William Pratt is Boris Karloff's real name
All Comments | Link13 | WaverleyJun 8, 2013 @ 4:13pm
Great ep. Pity about the microphone dropping into shot when Kate and Angel are in Kate's office :-/
All Comments | Link14 | NixJul 28, 2014 @ 12:38pm
That's not the only inversion in the William -> Spike turning. He also switched from being a, well, *oversensitive* sort, an upper-class twit gushing bad poetry over his doomed intended, to a football hooligan (though he stayed completely driven by the women he loved).
All Comments | Link15 | BoscalynJun 6, 2016 @ 2:53pm
Goof in this otherwise lovely episode: the preacher at Liam's funeral says Angel was barely twenty when he died; his gravestone lists him as dying at 26.
All Comments | Link16 | roseJul 11, 2016 @ 10:03pm
Replying to Boscalyn (#15)
I think he actually says "twenty and six", the preacher. That's what I hear at any rate, and transcripts (like this one from Buffyworld) seem to agree:

'Priest: “Taken too soon from the bosom of his family, a man of just 20 years and 6, Liam was well-loved by everyone he met. (?) Receive this your humble servant. We pray that you may take his eternal soul into your care, Father.” '
All Comments | Link17 | PoltargystNov 15, 2016 @ 5:28pm
They seem to be stepping away from the idea once voiced by Buffy that when you are turned into a vampire, nothing of you survives, a random demon inhabits your body. I'm glad. I think it is much more effective, much better for story telling purposes if you are the same person after being turned so that the issues faced in life continue on in afterlife.
All Comments | Link18 | alan24Dec 21, 2016 @ 5:39pm
Yes I agree. The BTVS standard theory of an entirely separate demon taking over the body was voiced by Giles in BTVS S1-1, and I think that at that point they just hadn't worked out what kind of stories they would want to tell in the years that followed. (In BTVS S1-2 we even had the Master saying to Luke “My soul is your soul”. Oops.)

The theory that works best for me (and is I think in the CT review of the previous episode to this one) is that being turned into a vampire removes the ability to feel caring love for any other person. There are wobbles in this (soulless Spike manages to show care for Dru, Buffy and indeed the entire Summers family, many times) but it fits with most of the stories. While in this episode, Darla's joy in the turned-Liam is not caring: she is simply thrilled by his violence and viciousness.

Incidentally: this is an illuminating review, adding to the episode.
Post a Comment
Allowed tags: [i], [b], [u], [quote], [link=]
Name
Reply To
NOTE: Before commenting please read the review, argue/augment the points made in it, and be respectful of opposing opinions.
*** COPY YOUR COMMENT (in case of posting failure)! ***


Security Code
Security Code

  

Copyright © 2005-2017 Critically Touched. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of any review or article on this site is prohibited. For questions regarding specific content, please click on the author's name to find their contact information. You can contact the site creator, Mikelangelo Marinaro, at: mikejer[at]criticallytouched[dot]com. All works and related characters are property of the production companies associated with the content. Critically Touched has no affiliation with with any of these companies.