| STYLES: STANDARD | PRINT | NAVIGATE: ⇩ CRITICALLYTOUCHED.COM |
|
| home | reviews | articles | links | discussion |
| Writer: | Joss Whedon |
| Director: | Joss Whedon |
| - | Quick Links |
| - | Review |
This is a great season opener! When I saw this episode for the first time I wasn't nearly as enthused about it for some reason. I remember being really bored of the Anointed One and the couple things that bugged me really stuck out. The music in the training session really grated on me along with Buffy being a little too bitchy to her friends. Aside from these complaints, though, there's really nothing else in this episode that I don't like, which makes my original impression of this episode drastically unfounded.
At the very beginning I noticed a really sweet "previously on Buffy..." sequence that recaps most of the big events in S1. This is fantastic and I wish they'd included one of these at the beginning of every season (or maybe they just left them out on the DVD sets). I've been introducing a lot of people to 'Buffy' lately and I usually start them off with "School Hard" (2x03); that seems to be working perfectly. I think I'm going to play this recap first, though. It gives a lot of backstory really quickly, which is good, because explaining all the stuff that happened can be confusing and annoying to a 'Buffy' virign. Anyway...
Pretty much everyone is a little different at the beginning of this episode. Everyone's personalities are where we last left them, but many of the relationships have flourished during the summer. First off is an emotionally distant Buffy, who we discover was away in Los Angeles with her dad (a.k.a. Mr. MIA Jerk who runs to Spain with chicks and abandons his daughter in future seasons). More on our not-so-lovely Buffy later. Next we've got Willow and Xander who's relationship has gotten a bit more intimate since we left them. Willow obviously still has the hots for Xander, but this is the first time we see romantic interest in Willow from Xander. They have a cute scene involving ice cream on Willow's nose which gets interrupted by a lousy vampire. Also on the slate of change is Giles and Jenny. They have really progressed their relationship and have turned into two flirting adults who are obviously about to go out on a date (and they do in the next episode). Cordelia, on the other hand, is pretty much the same where we last saw her, thankfully still being more friendly to the group yet not losing the snide remarks.
Now we get back to Buffy, who's in all-out angst mode. We find out very early on that the root of her problem is how traumatized she is from being killed (drowned) by the Master in "Prophecy Girl" (1x12). She hasn't told anyone about how scared and shaken up she is all summer long. I'm glad that event was not forgotten. I'm particularly impressed by Sarah Michelle Gellar here when she visually shows, by subtly shaking when walking up the Master's grave after it's dug out as an example, just how frightened she is of the thought of him coming back. All of this emotion being bottled up for that long is going to make you into a meaner individual, which is exactly what happens to Buffy here.
While I think the writers took her angst too far, most of it was believable and spot-on. The way this is dealt with is with a satisfying scene at the end where Buffy smashes the bones of the Master into pieces with a sledgehammer, then breaks down and weeps in Angel's arms. Her tears here serve as a means to wash away her ordeal with The Master for good. The moral of the story is that keeping your emotions bottled up for long periods of time is not healthy and will only lead to hurtful comments to your friends and loved ones. Instead, one should confide with those same friends as they will always be there to help you through times of need, as is displayed at the end when Willow and Xander save Buffy a seat in class.
The main plot was on the mediocre side but it got the job done. Due to the wonderful character interaction and drama, this is the perfect foundation and launching point for this season's maelstrom of emotion. I have come to really appreciate this episode.
| - | Minor Pros/Cons (+/-) |
| Pros: | |
| + | Xander still has the hots for Buffy. The moment she comes back he forgets about Willow in the romantic way. |
| + | The bet Willow and Xander made on how long it would take Giles to consult his books. |
| + | The training session including Giles getting his ass kicked again. |
| + | Buffy's dream about Giles choking her only to reveal The Master underneath. |
| + | While a little stalker-esque, I enjoyed Angel's late night visit to Buffy's room and their short conversation. |
| + | The follow-up on the ice cream nose later in The Bronze. Willow is so sad but still cute when Xander pushes off her hints for Buffy. |
| + | The famous "sexy dance" with Xander was both very sexy and very cold. |
| + | Cordelia attempting to help Buffy out. "Get over it." |
| + | Giles' disgusted reaction to drinking the pink soda; so totally in character. |
| + | While earlier Xander gives Willow the romantic push-off, he proves she's still his best friend by telling Buffy, "if they hurt Willow, I'll kill you." |
| + | Buffy torturing that female vampire by sticking a cross in her mouth and forcing it shut. |
| + | When asked how she is going to distract the vamps, she says "I'm going to kill them all." This reminds me of a line in "Welcome to the Hellmouth" (1x01) where Angel and Buffy share this dialog exchange: |
| + | The fight at the end was well done and marks a big improvement over the S1 fight sequences. |
| Cons: | |
| - | The black preacher vamp is cliched from the start. |
| - | Foreshadowing |
|
| - | Quotes |
| CORDELIA: | I already have a lot of character. Is it possible to have too much character? |
| XANDER: | Yo! G-man! What's up? |
| GILES: | Nice to see you. And don't ever call me that. |
| WILLOW: | The other night I dreamt that Xander... Uh, I-it wasn't Xander. I-in fact it wasn't me. It was a friend's dream, and she doesn't remember it. |
| BUFFY: | I bet she doesn't. |
| BUFFY: | Willow, grow up. Not everything is about kissing. |
| XANDER: | (to Willow) Yeah. Some stuff's about groping. (to Buffy) It wasn't about groping? |
| WILLOW: | Cibo Matto? They're playing? |
| XANDER: | No, Willow, they're gonna be clog dancing. |
| WILLOW: | Cibo Matto can clog dance? (gets a look from Xander) Oh, sarcasm, right. |
| BUFFY: | Cordelia, your mouth is open and sound is coming from it. This is never good. |
| WILLOW: | That's what it was! I mean, why else would she be acting like such a b-i-t-c-h? |
| GILES: | Willow, I think we're all a little too old to be spelling things out. |
| XANDER: | A bitca? |
| SNYDER: | You really have faith in those kids, don't you? |
| GILES: | Yes, I do. |
| SNYDER: | Weird. |
| BUFFY: | You're a vampire. Oh, I'm sorry, was that an offensive term? Should I say 'undead American'? |
| XANDER: | Well, we could grind our enemies into talcum powder with a sledgehammer, but, gosh, we did that last night. |
| - | Score | Learn about the Grading Scale |
| 85/100 |
B+ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ |
Just misses the mark of excellence. Essentially, a great episode that's rough around the edges and/or slightly flawed. Extremely fun to watch.
|
| - | Screencaps |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| - |
Comments (32)
View Today's Comments |
Subscribe:
|
| 1. | MorrydwenFeb 26, 2006 (Sun)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| First off, I love reading these reviews. They're really great reading, insightful, and meticulously done. Great work! That said, I couldn't help noticing you missed a huge foreshadowing piece from "When She Was Bad". While still in "Joan Collins 'tude" mode, Buffy confronts Angel at one point and says the following Buffy: Oh, c'mon! I mean, you must've thought about it. What would happen if it ever came down to a fight, you vampire, me the Slayer, I mean, you must've wondered! Well, why don't we find out? (quote taken as typed up in the transcript at buffyworld.com) Hugely foreshadowing what the pinnacle of the season will be! I remembering noticing the first time I rewatched that episode knowing how S2 ended. Looking forward to more reviews...keep 'em coming! :) |
| 2. | MikeJerFeb 26, 2006 (Sun)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Welcome to the forums Morrydwen! Glad you've joined the ever growing crowd of wonderful and often-insightful forum members here. That is some sweet foreshadowing you picked up on there that I, in fact, somehow missed. I appreciate you pointing it out and will go add that right away! Please continue to feel free in pointing out things to make this site or my reviews even better (like you just did). Our debate on "The Freshman" here even encouraged me to raise the score by 5 points. The reviews will continue! |
| 3. | GroundedFeb 27, 2006 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I believe you've mistakenly given I Robot, You Jane 10 points when you actually meant 95. :O |
| 4. | AaronJerFeb 27, 2006 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| You know, Grounded, there are certain things in this world that are just NOT funny to joke about. I'm very disappointed in your lack of sympathy. |
| 5. | MorrydwenFeb 27, 2006 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Glad to help! And discussing this show is way too much fun to not join in! |
| 6. | MikeJerFeb 27, 2006 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Well, since you mentioned IRYJ I might as well mention that I plan on re-reviewing most, if not all, of S1 after I've finished the rest of the series. It's pretty obvious I hadn't quite decided how involved I wanted to get at that time. I feel those reviews are a bit of a letdown (I'm happy with the S1 Review though). |
| 7. | MezSep 20, 2006 (Wed)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I just realised how similar Buffy's character is here compared to the middle of Season 7. Mainly thinking about Get It Done and Dirty Girls. |
| 8. | LatoyaMay 1, 2007 (Tue)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I really sympathized with Buffy in this episode. She spent the entire summer having nightmares/prophetic dreams about the Master, the evil monster that murdered her! Can you imagine how you would be if you had the memory of that creature paralysing your body, coming up behind you, sinking his fangs into your neck, and drinking your blood while telling you that the YOU are the reason that he will be able to enter the world again and wreck havok. That if you hadn't done this selfless act he wouldn't have been freed. Giles understood that she was acting the way she was for a reason. He knew that she was in a great deal of pain and was hiding her emotions. She did try to open up. In that bedroom scene when Angel said he missed her. She turned to him with a lot of emotion and said "I miss you". You could tell she was about to confide in him but he had left. |
| 9. | LibMaxAug 23, 2007 (Thu)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| To me, When She Was Bad was perhaps the most disappointing episode of Season Two. Not the worst - there were plenty of bad episodes in this best of seasons / worst of seasons. But it deals with a great premise - how bad would it be if The Slayer started to indulge her moods and her temper and used her powers to make her problems into everyone's problems? Hey, I'd been wondering about that! How bad *would* it be? Well, she might start - I dunno - saying snotty things and, uh, being mean to her friends and, uh, being bossy and, uh, using a friend who had a crush on her to make her boyfriend jealous. You know, like that other infamous Slayer-gone-bad, Cordelia. This episode opens wide the Gates of Hell and sends forth a hamster with halitosis. And, maybe to make up for it, the dialog is overwritten, on-the-nose and in-your-face ("You want to kill them - you want to kill them all!"?? "C'mon! Kick my ass!"?????). It's as if they were trying too hard to tell us, to make up for not being willing to show us. This is maybe the clunkiest dialog of any Joss Whedon BTVS episode. It doesn't help that we are still mired in the schlock of Season One when it comes to villains. This is perhaps The Annoying One's biggest episode, although it does contain his one and only decent line reading ("I *hate* that girl!"). And Absolom is more long-winded and boring than The Master at his worst, or even Luke. I'm glad ME finally realized (with Spike and Drusilla) that we can tell who to root for without having to hate every second that the villains are on screen, wishing that they would STFU and go away. |
| 10. | buffyholicAug 30, 2007 (Thu)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I have to say this is a great opener. Everyone here is amazing, the dialogue continues to be awesome. My favorite scenes are when Buffy dreams that Giles is the Master; and the awesome Bronze scene: the music is awesome and Buffy is surprisingly a bitch, causing everyone to be uncomfortable. Very good, indeed. |
| 11. | Woohoo1729Dec 10, 2007 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Buffy's certainly bitchier here than any other moment in the series, as my memory currently serves me. Way over-the-top, but I guess the extreme degree MIGHT be understandable, I'm still not sure if it DOES for sure make complete sense given what she's gone through...but for sure, not a shining moment for Buffy the character. Thank God her friends don't hold grudges, cuz I personally remember every instance in my past where a friend has blown up at me like that. |
| 12. | AndrewJan 4, 2008 (Fri)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Funny, I actually thought the black preacher was pretty cool; certainly miles better than the Master. Even The Annointed One didn't bother me quite as much as in Season 1. I enjoyed this episode immensely. The main plot was admittedly not terribly exciting, but all the stuff going on with Xander, Willow and Buffy was very well done. |
| 13. | TelmorJan 24, 2009 (Sat)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| About Buffy's bitchiness in this episode: She comments several times in other episodes that pre-slayer she was rather shallow and even Cordelia-esque, so the behaviour this episode could be seen as a throw-back to her old, teen bitch queen, self. On the episode, it definitely has it's moment of brilliant dialogue, but on a whole, not one of my favourites. Far from one of the worst this season, though. |
| 14. | EmilyFeb 13, 2009 (Fri)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I just wanted to say that I really love Angel's lines in this episode: 1- "I missed you." 2- "Why are you ridin' me?" I have to admit that I love how Angel's character is developed throughout the whole show- I actually like him better when he's in BtVS than when he's in AtS. |
| 15. | SamMar 17, 2009 (Tue)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| This is without question one of my favorite episodes. Even though I don't dislike S1 as much as most people on this board do, When She Was Bad is a beautiful, ominous harbinger of things to come. It is bolder, darker, and sexier than anything we had seen before, and it brings to the foreground the dark, Gothic hybrid of ominous horror and star-crossed supernatural romance. I love how coldly Buffy treated her friends in this episode. It really put her through the ringer, but ultimately she comes out the other side. This one's a knockout. |
| 16. | SeleneJul 6, 2009 (Mon)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| There is one thing about this episode that pissed me off to no end: Buffy knew how Willow felt about Xander, but still did her slut-it-up dance with him right in Willow's face and never apologized once she'd 'gotten over' her 'issues.' This is how you treat your supposed best friend? |
| 17. | nallanSep 8, 2009 (Tue)View This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Love these reviews...thanks mikejer :)
Just finished re-watching this episode and although I found the actual plot kinda boring, I really liked the character development, SMG really conveys the emotions that Buffy is feeling, it almost painful to watch...in a good way of course... :) I REALLY liked the Cordelia/Buffy dialogue outside the Bronze, it's onvious that they are ttrying to integrate her into the show more. All in all, I loved this season opener, better than some other ones for sure :) |
| 18. | DFAS GilesOct 23, 2009 (Fri) @ 8:25pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I can't believe how much Buffy resembled Faith in this episode, especially some of her expressions and body language in the alley with Angel. |
| 19. | Vera@AmsterdamNov 16, 2009 (Mon) @ 6:16amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Spank your inner moppet or whatever. Best line of the episode. love Cordelia anywayzz so.
How I have not found this site before is a puzzle to me. You can debate and everything. I thought I was the only buffy watcher this long after the show stopped. At least once a year I watch the show from S1 through S7. Great to read more people are still watching. |
| 20. | Smallprint84Mar 3, 2010 (Wed) @ 5:01amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| This S2 opening credits is so badass. It rocks!! Too bad the audio-version changed forever with S3.
Plus a great episode btw. Cibo Matto, sexy dance, emotional issues, what more do you need? |
| 21. | David@PragueMar 31, 2010 (Wed) @ 3:45pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| I guess I am too big a loser to expect some plot & at least half hearted attempt for logic and credibility? ***SPOILERS*** Come on you ppl, vampires leaving beaten Xander in the library without drinking him ? Are we still talking vampires here ?! Also vampires could have easily drunk whole Sunnydale several nearby states while Buffy was on holiday. It really cries for presenting any excuse why they stayed hidden till Buffy returned. Vapmires are really shown as sorry lot ... it makes me to pity them instead of fear / hate them. In S1 - Angel epizode it was stated very clearly that vampires can not enter unless invited. Since then I have seen at least 5 epizodes when they broke inside buldings without invitation. I guess even vampires can learn some new tricks probably, huh ? 5 of 10 (for ice cream, Snyder scenes, sexy dance, shocked Cornelia and for attempt to show emotionally challenged Buffy) |
| 22. | GuidoMar 31, 2010 (Wed) @ 8:37pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| David, an inscription on the outside of the school reads, "Formatia trans sicere educatorum" (Enter all ye who seek knowledge), which serves as a standing invitation (unintended?) to vampires to enter the school. This is revealed in Passion. Xander wakes up from behind a big table, which suggests that he fell there during the fight, and was overlooked. I would think, also, that the vamps were under instructions not to feed and to bring back only the Scoobs that mattered. |
| 23. | John RobertsSep 13, 2010 (Mon) @ 10:38amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Well, I had fun.
Somehow I was under the impression that this wasn't a good episode, which was reinforced by the cheesy, predictable beginning -- a baddie just happens to come out of nowhere after a summer of dormancy, and by gosh yes Buffy is there at the very second she is needed. Yawn. But it got very good after that. Sarah was terrific; she got a chance to show her stuff and she nailed it. Tough to display a sudden character change without it seeming forced, but to me it was fully believable. She was defiled by her contact with The Master. He made her feel cheap. Low. A slut. (Once again, I read a sexual element into their contact.) Her self loathing came to the fore in that remarkable dance with Xander, a dance so cruel and contemptible that Buffy could not complete it. Throughout the show, Buffy is confident against the baddies (except The Master), a boldness that I initially regarded as a growth in character -- a sign of what she had learned by conquering The Master. But at the end, when she falls to pieces smashing the skeleton to pieces, I realized that her alleged confidence was a front. Like smiling brightly while thinking about the whispers. So it made perfect sense to me when she collapsed in Angel's arms. That was her point of progress. A dark step forward in Buffy's characterization. |
| 24. | debisibDec 22, 2010 (Wed) @ 10:31amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| the song as the episode ends is the greatest song ever made... or worst. yea probably worst. |
| 25. | CoyoteBuffyFanFeb 13, 2011 (Sun) @ 9:25amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| This was a decent episode. Not a blockbuster but not a bust either.
This episode does have one of the most memorable scenes in the entire show IMO. The sexy dance scene has always stuck with me. I think of it often when I think back on the show. Not because it is sexy (it is) but because I think it a perfectly executed scene. The music is fantastic, the acting is superb (Xander, Willow and Angel's reaction are all totally on point and you can just tell so much about their characters just by their facial expressions - great acting), and the scene is so uncomfortable that it works. The scene delivers emotionally in so many ways -- you can feel Buffy's pain, you can feel Xander's desire coupled with confusion and knowledge that it isn't right, you can feel Willow's pain, and you can feel Angel's jealousy. I love that scene. The rest of the episode is pretty meh. Xander provides some good comic relief and Cordelia's line about spanking her inner moppet is great. When Buffy smashes The Master's bones, it is a great release for her and makes us all feel better, like everything will be alright again. My biggest beef with the episode is the end music. My god, it's awful. It's music straight out of a cheesy after school episode. If I turned on the TV and that scene was playing with Xander, Willow, and Buffy in the classroom, I would never watch the show. |
| 26. | LeadJun 12, 2011 (Sun) @ 9:32amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| This episode was very well directed (with perhaps one of the most well-edited scenes I have ever seen in the form of Buffy's sexy dance with Xander at the Bronze). I am glad that the writers were wise enough to not just brush aside what happened to Buffy in Prophecy Girl. This is a sign that Season One's episodic amnesia (as the reviewer has taken to calling it, I believe) has come to an end, and the writers are ready to deal with serious issues. "When She Was Bad" is a very dark episode for this early in the series. It raises the bar on everything: the fight at the end, the music (except for that horrible after-school special music near the end when Buffy has made up with the Scoobies), the direction, the writing, everything takes a huge step up here. Also, the ending is hilarious ("I hate that girl!"). Like you, Mikejer, I didn't really appreciate this the first time I saw it. In retrospect, it is a really awesome episode, though. It is interesting how different my impression of various episodes is getting now that I am rewatching everything in order. This is, to my mind, A-range material (90/100). Not as good as the great episodes, but still really good. |
| 27. | smallprint84Jul 27, 2011 (Wed) @ 4:45amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Also a plus: that horrible score of S1 is gone!
Welcome Chris Beck!!! A great improvement. |
| 28. | LouisaOct 29, 2011 (Sat) @ 5:24pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Buffy spent a summer in LA recovering from a life and death trauma, then came back and was mean to her friends. Maybe they did kind of hold it against her. A year later she spends a summer in LA recovering from a life and death trauma, then comes back and her friends are mean to her. |
| 29. | Gemma Dec 7, 2011 (Wed) @ 1:51pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| This episode allowed us to explore Buffy the aftermath. The Master not only killed Buffy but he scared her, he made her feel and experience how short her life span actually could be. So many shows don't look into the psychology of the characters but When She Was Bad didn't disappoint. We saw the trauma she went through and this episode was sort of like us watching Buffy on a shrinks couch going through the motions as it were a little of a foreshadow to season six when we see Buffy cope and grow and deal with having been dead and content in heaven. We were given particular perception to how Buffy spent her summer vacation being introspective and turning over what she went through in her head instead of coping. The connection her friends have with her is shown and acted well in this episode, they become aware of Buffy having an underlying problem and that theres something she isn't coming to terms with. This compelling look into Buffy's fears through her dreams of The Master being back was a great way to go and her slow walk to The Master's grave. The premise that Buffy has come back wrong, or at least not the same is a foreshadow of Season six. Looking retrospectively it is possible to suggest that Buffy's attitude is her on the verge of being Faith, what saves her from this path is defeating her fears and collapsing into Angel's arms. This moment of weakness is Buffy's salvation. Viewers may look at and dismiss that moment but to me i think it was the most important of the episode. |
| 30. | Gemma Dec 7, 2011 (Wed) @ 2:05pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| One other moment that could be considered foreshadowing is when Buffy comes back to the library and finds only Xander; this is similar to the situation in Becoming pt 2 when she arrives back and it is Xander she first sees after Kendra. Further more is it possible to argue that when Buffy was working out her issues fighting and killing the vampires at the end of this episode to link this to her working out her issues in season six with Spike, there was some fighting before the erm other scenes but it screams to me that Buffy turned to the darkness or the danger in her life to sort of find a solace? I could be way of base and completely deficient in my thinking ...what do others think? |
| 31. | fray-adjacentDec 7, 2011 (Wed) @ 10:38pmView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Hey Gemma, It's been nice reading your comments the last few days. You'll get a lot more responses if you join the forum and post your thoughts there! Hope to see you there. :) |
| 32. | Gemma Dec 8, 2011 (Thu) @ 4:45amView This Person's Comments | Link | |
| Hi fray-adjacent, Thanks, Its nice to know that someone is reading :) I hope they make sense and that i'm not way of base! I took your advice and joined the forum today my user name if you're interested is WttHM (After one of my favourite episodes Welcome to the Hellmouth) |
| - | Post a Comment |
|
Name
(NOTE: Before posting your opinion on this episode, please remember to read the review, be respectful of opposing opinions, and to competently use at least basic spelling and grammar. The administrator has the right to remove a comment at any time.) (*** copy your comment in case of failure!!! ***) Security Code |